Don Corleone

Hard to believe, but there you have it. This little island restaurant toward the north end of Front Street is decorated with posters and art from the Godfather movies, and other Italian-themed items. The dark, finished wood furniture is elegant without compromising the casual island feel. This is the best-reviewed eatery on the island.

Although we didn't get a chance to eat dinner here, the menu looked incredibly tempting. Typical Italian pasta dishes and desserts. We did have breakfast here. The crepes with pineapple and Nutella (spreadable chocolate) were incredible. My sister enjoyed her Eggs Benedict, as well. If the dinners are half as good as the breakfast, you can't go wrong with this place!