Brother's Pizza

  based on 1 review   write a review

750 Port Richmond Avenue Staten Island, Staten Island, NY, USA

Brother's Pizza Staten Island Reviews

NJTProadcruiser NJTProad…
38 reviews
Excellent Pizzeria on Staten Island Jan 21, 2011
Brother's Pizza is one of the absolute best pizza places on Staten Island. Everything that I have had here has been nothing short of excellent. The staff has garnered well-deserved nationwide attention, most recently being featured on Live With Regis and Kelly.

The regular slices ($2.50) each are excellent, cooked to perfection, the cheese, the sauce, a crust thats just right, its just an excellent slice of pizza!

The Sicilian slice ("A square"), excellent, again, just an absolutely delicious slice.

The Chicago-style slice ("A pan slice"), $3.75 again excellent!

The Grandma slice, maybe its a NY thing, but its a thinner square slice with fresh mozzarella, a different tomato sauce. Its kinda hard to explain but the slice is excellent.

I have also had their Buffalo slice (i think its discontinued, but was excellent), chicken rolls, sausage and pepper rolls, all excellent!

Brother's Pizza also serves various appetizers (mozzarella sticks, rice balls, garlic knots), salads, pasta and meat dishes as well..

Best Pros: They're always busy so you will almost always get a fresh slice. They are also open late, closing between midnight and 1am Sun-Thurs and closing 1am-2am Friday and Saturday nights...

Parking can be tricky, there's a lot in the back but with 12 spaces shared with a deli..

The pizzeria has a nice large area to sit down, however there is no wait staff,, you must do all the ordering (including drinks - no alcohol) and payment at the counter, if you order a pie, someone will bring it to you.. The only downfall is, is that it does get a little noisy in the dining area, but thats it...

Also, there is no delivery and everything is cash only, an ATM machine is available.

If you are on Staten Island, NY stop in for one of the boroughs best eats.
Brother's Pizza
4 / 4 TravBuddies found this review helpful/trustworthy
HuBison says:
I must admit, I do like Staten Island pizza, but pretty much, any pizza in NY is going to satisfy my tummy...hmmmmm.
Posted on: Mar 15, 2011
rrodjr1931 says:
Congrats on the feature. Love Love Love Pizza. mmmm. My absolute favorite is L&B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn. Way better than overrated Grimaldi's. LOL.
Posted on: Jan 22, 2011
nyprne says:
Nice featured review, Mike. I prefer Pizza from the Bronx but can't deny pizza from elsewhere in sound mind. Cheers!
Posted on: Jan 22, 2011
Join TravBuddy to leave comments, meet new friends and share travel tips!

Check Staten Island Hotel Deals

Brother's Pizza Map
1 review
1 review
1 review
2 reviews - $159
1 review - $145
Staten Island
photo by: chimiloca